Small Business Debt As a Security- Issuing Equity

issuing small business equity and securities

Four Factors for Small Business Owners When Issuing Equity

 

 

In a previous article—Keys to Issuing Equity for Small Business Owners—we covered the idea that issuing shares of stock, or membership interests, in a business could trigger obligations under the securities laws.

More specically we discussed that issuing equity interests to even friends and family could trigger disclosure obligations. What we did not address was the question of whether issuing debt, like issuing promissory notes to potential investors, could also trigger application of the securities laws.

While the issuing of stock is a classic example of a transaction where the securities laws apply, the issuing of debt instruments like “promissory notes” presents a less clear-cut picture.

The most significant legal authority on this subject is the U.S. Supreme Court opinion in the case–Reves v. Ernst & Young—wherein Justice Marshall discussed the standard that should be used to determine whether the securities laws apply to debt-instruments, like promissory notes.

That case involved an agricultural cooperative which issued promissory notes to its members to help raise capital, in the form of loans.

The notes that were issued paid a variable rate of interest to holders, and were “demand” notes, meaning that the holder could demand repayment of the debt at any time. As it happened, the cooperative ended up becoming insolvent and going into bankruptcy, leaving in the lurch almost 1,600 note holders holding, collectively, about $10 million of debt.

The note holders ended up suing the accounting firm, which had audited the cooperative’s financials, for securities fraud.

Their claim against Ernst & Young was that it had overvalued certain assets, which created the false impression that the cooperative was sounder financially than it really was.

In determining whether the notes were “securities,” Justice Marshall, writing for the majority of the Supreme Court, pointed to the statutory definition of “securities” which included “notes” with maturities exceeding nine months.  He explained, however, that not all notes were traditionally thought of as vehicles of investment.

Adopting the Second Circuit’s “family resemblance” approach, Justice Marshall explained that there were certain categories of notes that were more clearly not securities.

These notes included the following;

  • Notes delivered in consumer financing
  • Notes secured by a mortgage on a home
  • Short-term notes secured by a lien on a small business or some of its assets
  • Notes that are “character” loans to a bank customer
  • Short term notes secured by an assignment of accounts receivable
  • Notes which formalize an open-account debt incurred in the ordinary course of business,
  • Notes evidencing loans by commercial banks for current operations

The idea was that all notes were presumed to be “securities” unless they held a “strong” “family resemblance” to one of the above listed types of notes that were considered to be exempt from the securities laws.

Next page- The Court looked at 4 factors and The Takeaway

RELATED POSTS

4 Definitive Examples to Understand and Serve Your Customers

4 Definitive Examples to Understand and Serve Your Customers

These four company case studies have yielded success across industries Running on Innovation, A New Solution for City Dwellers, Focus on Customers. Learn from these companies that are doing it right. Recently, I attended a public forum called Healthcare in the 21st...

4 Components of Small Business Agility in a Diverse Market

4 Components of Small Business Agility in a Diverse Market

Small business leaders need to understand diversity in order to be connected and create opportunities for success   The model of how to effectively navigate business leadership is changing. For decades stability and homogeneity were hallmarks of business across...

Top 7 Ways to Show Your Customers You Care

Top 7 Ways to Show Your Customers You Care

Even a small gesture can go a long way with a client and will be appreciated.   Nowadays, having a good product or service isn’t enough. Relationships are the differentiator. Today many companies are making investments in customer advocacy and loyalty programs...

Video Gallery

Modern version of Stoic philosopher Epictetus
A professional leads a cybersecurity training session for employees, emphasizing best practices. The photography captures the engagement of participants, showcasing the educational aspect of safeguard
Hispanic bearded male businessman trainer teaching coaching new recruitment African American female businesswoman employee in formal suit sitting studying learning company graph chart strategy
The presence of a robot using a computer. Office keyboard being typed on by machine. future IT group,.
Latino Streetwear Entrepreneur Latin Biz Today
Chef Lorena Garcia cooking with a wok
Latina Chef Loren Garcia
Latin Biz Today partner Johanna at the San Sebastián Festival

Polls

Which item currently represents the greatest hurdle in the growth of your business?(Required)

Sign Up for the Latin Biz Today Newsletter

PR Newswire

Featured Authors

Innovation & Strategy

Money

Four Basic Principles for Raising Capital

Four Basic Principles for Raising Capital

Outside investors want to understand a business' strategy as well as its financial statements.   The need to raise capital from outside investors requires a great deal of preparation across multiple dimensions. Among many things, investors look to understand...

Talent/HR

Legal

Marketing

Culture

Fashion

Food

Music

Sports

Work & Life

Mindfulness

Health & Fitness

Travel & Destinations

Personal Blogs

Pin It on Pinterest